Disguised

The arrested man first identified himself as David Casey Horn, a 38-year-old tobacco farm worker from Loris, South Carolina. But his name and age sent a red flag to Brad Brekke, a Florida FBI agent, who stumbled across the case in the local newspaper. He had been looking for Paul David Crews, a 38-year-old fugitive who had become a drifter after being indicted for the murder of Clemmie Jewel Arnold in Bartow, Florida in July 1986.

Most wanted

It was reported by the Sentinel in October 1990 that Crews was wanted in Florida on a first-degree murder charge. Since disappearing from Florida in 1986 for the brutal murder of Arnold, Crews had been on the most-wanted list in that state. He had been indicted by a Polk County, Florida, grand jury for the murder.