Though Eaton’s DNA was undoubtedly linked to the crime scene, prosecutors were faced with a myriad of complications. For one, they couldn’t prove that Eaton had intentionally murdered Amber, so they had to settle for reckless homicide charges.”Given the facts of the case, I believe a jury would very likely pass on intentional (homicide) and focus on reckless homicide, and the (amended charge) reflects what the evidence would probably show,” Racine County Assistant District Attorney Robert Repischak said. Furthermore, the defense team came up with a theory that the prosecution was not anticipating…

Following Eaton’s arrest, new information emerged about a man from Amber’s past that may have been responsible for the murder. The judge allowed evidence to be admitted that poked holes in the burden of proof that the prosecution had. The man claimed that he had a sexual history with Amber and his incredible account of their relationship had others questioning Eaton’s role in the murder…