Sisters

Sherri’s sister, Sheila Koester, who was seven months pregnant at the time of Sherri’s disappearance, told journalists, “She was out for a run. She wouldn’t leave her babies. She has a family that loves her. Please just bring her home.”  Even the 36-year-old older sister of Keith, Suzanne Papini went on to say “She’s here with them [her family] every day gardening and doing projects. There’s just no way she would just take off.”

Ransom Money Offered

It had been more than a week with no sign of Sherri anywhere. The Papini family decided to offer a $50,000 reward for any information on where she could be. They also started a GoFundMe account, hoping to raise money to aid in the investigation. Supposedly, they even raised up to $50,000 through the site alone.