A Few Key Witnesses, 1 Guilty Mother And 25 Years Later, This Cold Case Is Finally Solved

The Carnival Is Temporarily Closed

Source: Star-Ledger and NJ.com Staff Report

When Michelle realizes that her precious son is missing, her scream is said to be deafening. Police immediately arrive on the scene and they temporarily shut down the carnival in the hopes of finding Timmy right away. Michelle would even tell police, “He doesn’t like to wait on lines.” Timmy was also said to be wearing a red tank top and a pair of sneakers.

Searching Everywhere

Source: Screenshot from https://morbidology.com/

Not only did the State Police search the entire carnival grounds, they made sure to send in a helicopter, scent-sniffing dogs and even scuba divers to make sure that they had a chance to double check the nearby ponds. But when the search garnered nothing, they had to quit when the time reached 2 a.m. to resume just 3 hours after at 5 a.m. But even then, they wouldn’t find a single trace of Timmy anywhere.

Popular on True Activist