Incriminating Evidence

When police began to search his house, they would find all the incriminating evidence that they would need to put him behind bars. The Adidas shoes that matched the footprints they had found at two of the crime scenes were sitting in the closet. Then they found the gloves that had created the honeycomb pattern they had found on the windows as well. The black scarf he used to cover his face was inside the bathroom, and they also found the Ruger .380-calibre gun, as well as the pink camera stolen and used, all inside the backpack he would bring along with him during his attacks.

He Kept Trophies

Det. Galbraith would also soon discover the ‘trophies’ of O’Leary’s conquests. Victims had shared that they were missing their underwear, and they found most of it kept inside one piece of his stereo equipment. They even found the lubricant and wet wipes he used. Det. Galbraith even said, “He was military, so he was very organized. This was the cleanest house I’ve ever searched.”