American Girl “Meet Molly” Doll, $5,000

Back in 1986, the Pleasant Company began to sell their American Girl dolls, which are still sold up to today. And even though these dolls cost around $100 to $120 a pop, some of the much older versions like this ‘Meet Molly’ doll can sell for $5,000 as long as she comes with her original clothes and other accessories. If you were lucky enough to own one when you were younger, you may want to check your parents’ basement one of these days… just in case.

Peanut Royal Blue Elephant Beanie Baby, $5,000

Beanie Babies come in a variety of colors, shapes and sizes, but this original navy blue “Peanut” elephant happens to be the most valuable of them all. When she was first put into production, her color came out much darker than what the company wanted, so only 2000 pieces were created. This made its value go up to an unbelievable $5,000.