This man had also submitted DNA to eliminate him as a suspect, but it only led to more questions. His DNA was found to be a contributor to the DNA mixture located on the victim’s underwear by the Wisconsin State Crime Lab. His DNA was also located at the crime scene, according to the defense attorneys. It was what was found on the garbage bag that turned out to seal the fate of all involved. 

When testing the fingerprints found on the garbage bag placed over Amber’s head, investigators came across undeniable evidence: James Eaton’s fingerprints were all over the bag. This proved without a doubt that he had a hand in her death and caused the judge to move on with his charges.