Stevie Allman Was Actually Her Sister, Sarah Mitchell

After getting her fingerprints, authorities were going to unravel something much more perverse than what they could have ever thought. Not only was Stevie Allman not who she actually said she was, but she was really her younger sister, Sarah Allman Mitchell, who was pretending to be her older sister, Stevie.

She Had A Previous Record

Apparently, the alleged Stevie’s fingerprints had turned up a 1971 prostitution charge under the name of Sarah Mitchell. She even had a record for welfare fraud under her name as well. So when authorities questioned her again with all this ‘new’ information, she confessed that was undeniably impersonating her older sister, Stevie Allman.